and Zoroastrian legal systems, highlighting the function of the judiciary, the social
standing of the judges in their respective societies and their relations vis-à-vis
jurisprudence. Since these legal systems are called ‘religious’ in legal literature,
giving the impression that it is religion which is their most important feature, it is
necessary to compare postulations of legal theory to legal practice in order to show
the relationship between theory and practice.
We can find in the works of some authors of comparative law (e.g. Sola
Ca?izares, Adolf Schnitzer and René David)1 the concept of religious legal system,
although the definition of religion itself is rather complex and subject to various
interpretations. To refer to just one obvious example, there is hardly any similarity
between the Chinese concepts of religion (universalism, Taoism, yin-yang school
etc.) and those of the revealed religions (the religions of the book). Moreover,
there are so many schools and interpretations within Hinduism that one can hardly
speak about any uniform ‘ism’. If religious foundations taken for granted in legal
literature are so diverse and complex, how much more the legal systems built
on them would be. Thus, it is problematic to put such different legal systems
under the aegis of one rather enigmatic category. With some exceptions, however,
these considerations are not present in comparative legal literature since in the
majority of cases it is the erudition and interest of the author and limited space
which determine what comes under the aegis of religious legal systems. Hindu law
and Islamic law are always discussed in comparative legal works because of their
importance, influence and the great number of their followers. By contrast, Jewish
and Canon law are discussed very briefly, if not omitted altogether; meanwhile
Zoroastrian law is considered as not worth mentioning. Consequently, not only
the definition of the term ‘religious legal system’ is missing, but also the exact
enumeration of the individual legal systems covered by this category.