This book would not have been written had it not been for my becoming
involved as a ‘confession expert’ in two Icelandic cases in 2011. The
cases involved the disappearances of two unrelated men, Gudmundur
Einarsson and Geirfinnur Einarsson, in January and November 1974,
respectively. At the end of December 1975 and beginning of January
1976, the Reykjav?k Criminal Investigation Police commenced murder
investigations without the victims’ bodies, a known crime scene, or
credible leads. Despite the investigations floundering on numerous
occasions, after eliciting confessions that were massively contradictory
and could not be independently corroborated, six young people were
convicted and imprisoned on the basis of their confessions. The convicted
persons Saevar Ciesielski, Kristj?n Vidarsson, Tryggvi Leifsson,
Gudj?n Skarphédinsson, Erla Bollad?ttir, and Albert Skaftason all
claimed to be innocent and alleged that their confessions were coerced
by the police. Saevar and Tryggvi are now dead, but the other four convicted
persons and the families of the two dead men are currently
fighting to have their convictions overturned.