Public participation is a vital part of constitution-making processes around the
world, but we know very little about the extent to which participation affects constitutional
texts. In this book, Alexander Hudson offers a systematic measurement of
the impact of public participation in three much-cited cases – Brazil, South Africa,
and Iceland – and introduces a theory of party-mediated public participation. He
argues that public participation has limited potential to affect the constitutional
text but that the effectiveness of participation varies with the political context. Party
strength is the key factor, as strong political parties are unlikely to incorporate public
input, while weaker parties are comparatively more responsive to public input.
This party-mediation thesis fundamentally challenges the contemporary consensus
on the design of constitution-making processes and places new emphasis on the role
of political parties.
Dr. Alexander Hudson is a Research Fellow in the Comparative Constitutionalism
Fellow Group at the Max Planck Institute for the Study of Religious and
Ethnic Diversity. His research focuses on the role of citizens in processes of constitutional
change, including participatory drafting processes, referendums, and
crowdsourcing.