This book develops and applies a new theoretical framework for thinking
and reasoning about the purpose, value, and social implications of environmental
protection policies. I rely most heavily on a particular theory of social
justice—the “capabilities approach” advanced by Martha Nussbaum—to provide
the framework’s guiding normative principle and basic conceptual logic.
The capabilities approach has much in common with rights-based approaches
to evaluating and designing policies because it treats individual-level political
protections as constitutional guarantees owed to citizens living in liberal
democratic societies. The individualistic focus has particular advantages
for addressing the inequitable impacts that environmental policies produce,
such as those that expose people to different levels of environmental
harm. The approach to designing and evaluating environmental policy that
I develop treats a certain level of environmental quality as an entitlement
to which each individual citizen has a basic political guarantee. However,
I define this individual guarantee in terms of a person’s capabilities rather
than a person’s rights. As a conception of individual well-being and advantage,
people’s capabilities are preferable to rights, most simply, because the
former defines a sphere of action that rights commonly protect, as well as the
preconditions that make it possible for people to engage in specific forms of
protected action. By extending the account of what is worthy of political protection
to include these enabling conditions I hope to advance an evaluative
framework that clarifies and reveals the vital role the natural environment
plays in a meaningful and flourishing human life, and therefore to affirm
environmental quality as a matter of basic political protection.
Environmental policy gives rise to many different kinds of questions.
Those that motivate the present project concern issues of valuation, justification,
and participation. How should we value the natural environment when
we assess the social value of policies that protect it? On what theA?oretical
and philosophical basis should we seek to justify environmental protection?
What role should citizens, experts, and various other stakeholders play in
environmental policy decisions? Because my intent is to bring a particular
theoretical approach to justice to bear on answering these questions,
this book is an exercise of applied political theory.